Table of Contents

7 Best Baby Crib Sheets – Cozy & Organic (2022 Reviews)

Baby playing in bed
Updated on

Preparing for a new baby can initially feel like a daunting and overwhelming endeavor. After all, welcoming home a new family member seemingly requires a lot of advanced preparation. From new furniture to diapers and wipes to every type of bottle on the market, it may seem like your shopping list only continues to grow. Luckily, a newborn actually requires very little in the early days. Outside of something to eat, something to wear, and a safe place to sleep, there isn’t much else you need to purchase ahead of time.

However, of these items, it’s extremely important you set up a safe space for your little one to go when you can’t hold him or her, such as a crib. Once you have a crib set up with a securely fitted mattress, it’s essential to choose a soft and safe bedding option. Baby crib sheets come in a variety of styles and fabrics that can be hard to decipher. Luckily, this selection of baby crib sheets offers a variety of natural as well as organic fabrics that are sure to not only be comfortable but also the safest options for your sleeping arrangements. From soothing pastels to charming patterns, you’ll be sure to find the perfect match for your nursery.

The Best Baby Crib Sheets

  • 1. Newton Baby Organic Fitted Crib Sheet

    (Softest choice — $$)

    Why it’s great: 100% breathable and ultra-soft, organic muslin cotton is machine washable and makes for the most hygienic sleep surface. The all-around elastic bottom guarantees a secure, safe fit on all standard size mattresses.

    Keep in mind: The 100% breathability of these sheets means some users found them to be on the thinner side compared to other crib sheets.

    Good for: Parents who prioritize softness for their infants.

  • 2. Burt’s Bees Baby Fitted Crib Sheet

    (Best option for varying sized cribs or bassinet — $)

    Why it’s great: Offering various sizes for your bassinet, mini crib, or full size crib, you can be sure to have a secure, safe fit on whichever sleeping surface you opt to use for your infant. An additional fabric overlap on the bottom edge along with 100% organic, GOTS certified and breathable cotton makes this an all-round great choice for your little one to have a good night’s rest.

    Keep in mind: The crib sheet offers a tight, secure fit on the mattress, so there isn’t much stretch when putting the sheet on.

    Good for: Parents who need sheets for varying-sized, safe sleeping surfaces for babies.

  • 3. American Baby Company Printed 100% Natural Cotton Jersey Knit Fitted Crib Sheet

    Why it’s great: With a myriad of charming prints to choose from, this 100% natural cotton jersey knit is perfect for any nursery theme. With a worn-in t-shirt feel and quality design, your little one is sure to feel extra cozy while sleeping on these baby crib sheets.

    Keep in mind: Due to the type of natural fabric, it can be difficult to remove some stains without the use of harsh chemicals.

    Good for: Parents who prefer a jersey knit fabric for their baby’s crib.

  • 4. HonestBaby Baby Organic Cotton Fitted Crib Sheet

    (Most versatile patterns — $$)

    Why it’s great: From endearing giraffes to classic stripes, the HonestBaby Baby Organic Cotton Fitted Crib Sheets will fulfill any little one’s early interests. Made from 100% organic materials, these sheets are created without the use of synthetic pesticides, and are non-toxic, PVC free and made without heavy metal phthalate dyes.

    Keep in mind: The material washes and dries well, but is not the softest of options available.

    Good for: Parents looking for organic baby crib sheets that fit their nursery’s interior design.

  • 5. Moonsea Store Organic Crib Sheet

    (Best budget option — $)

    Why it’s great: Finding an organic sheet option doesn’t need to break the bank. The Moonsea Store Organic Crib Sheet is made from 100% GOTS certified organic cotton and is free from all unwanted substances. Both durable and eco-friendly, these sheets are fade-resistant and easy to clean.

    Keep in mind: The breeziness and breathability of this material is on the thinner side of fabrics.

    Good for: Parents wanting an inexpensive organic option.

  • asher and lyricOn An Important Side Note… Asher and I (pictured) feel it’s necessary to highlight the value of life insurance for parents with young kids. After extensive research, we discovered that parents can get insured for as little as $10 per month. We use Ladder Life who offers coverage up to $3M per parent (without a medical exam, just a few health questions) and you can apply 100% online.

    Get a quote in less than 30 seconds at ➜

  • 6. Mosa Creations 100% Organic Fitted Crib Sheets Set

    (Best two pack option — $$)

    Why it’s great: Given the numerous stains that can appear overnight with a little one, this two pack guarantees you’ll have a spare sheet ready to go for middle of the night accidents. The soft, stretchy fit of this 100% GOTS certified organic jersey cotton makes it easy to clean and put on all standard size crib mattresses.

    Keep in mind: There are limited pattern options with this style sheet.

    Good for: Parents who don’t want to do laundry late at night.

  • 7. Touched By Nature Unisex Baby and Toddler Organic Cotton Crib Sheet

    (Best unisex options — $$)

    Why it’s great: The unisex design and pattern options on these sheets means it’s easy to pass these sheets on to siblings when the time comes. The soft, 100% organic cotton is ideal for everyday use while the full elastic bottom guarantees a tight, safe fit on most standard crib mattresses.

    Keep in mind: The soft cotton has a similar feel to flannel, which works for some infants and not others.

    Good for: Parents looking to keep sheets through multiple kids of both genders.

FAQs about Baby Crib Sheets

  • 1. What should I look for in a crib sheet?

    When looking to purchase a crib sheet, you want to ensure it has a tight, elastic fit around your crib mattress so it’s not a suffocation hazard. Look for soft, natural or organic fabrics that won’t irritate baby’s sensitive skin. Choosing soothing colors and soft patterns that don’t stimulate your baby may help him or her sleep more soundly.

  • 2. Why should I opt for natural or organic fabrics?

    It’s important to choose natural or organic fabrics to avoid any harsh materials that can irritate little one’s sensitive skin. You’ll also want to check that your chosen crib sheets haven’t been treated with dangerous chemicals or contaminates but are only made up of 100% natural materials.

  • 3. How many crib sheets do I need to own?

    From spit-up to leaky diapers to blowouts, you’ll want to be sure to have one or two spare crib sheets available for middle-of-the-night accidents. This prevents you from having to wait for a single sheet to be cleaned when you have a spare that can be used in emergencies.

  • 4. How do I care for my crib sheets?

    Be sure to follow the washing and drying guidance on the specific crib sheet you choose. Opt for a detergent free of allergens and harsh chemicals for washing. For tough stains, a mixture of white vinegar and baking soda can help get rid of marks without dangerous ingredients.

  • 5. How often do I need to replace crib sheets?

    If made of quality materials, your crib sheets should last for 2-3 years until your little one moves to a toddler bed. Your crib sheets will last even longer if you rotate between two or three sheets when one or two are in the wash. As with any item for your baby, be sure to continually check for holes, tears, or stains that no longer render the product safe for infant use.


The numerous options for crib bedding can initially be overwhelming. After all, your little ones are sure to spend many hours in their cribs so you want to know that they’re safe and comfortable. Choosing a natural or organic fabric is the ideal start to ensure your child’s skin isn’t irritated by synthetic materials or harsh chemicals used to treat certain fabrics. A soft, tight-fitting crib sheet with a strong, elastic bottom is the perfect resting place for your baby. These baby crib sheets all meet the necessary standards for safe sleeping while also providing numerous options of colors and patterns to coordinate with your nursery. You can be sure to find the perfect sheet that fosters a peaceful night of sleep for everyone in your family.